China Daily

Cao Cao from the Anyang excavation of the tomb from the day's debate on the authenticity of Cao Cao's tomb has been prevalent; the academic community thus divided into the "very Cao Group" and "anti-Cao faction." Anyang tomb of Cao Cao was named in 2009 after ten archaeological discoveries, the voices of doubt about the authenticity of Cao Cao's tomb has not disappeared, on Aug. 21, from "anti-Cao send" key figures, academics, launched six Ni side of "Three Kingdoms Culture National Forum "held in Suzhou. 23 around the country experts and scholars, from all of Cao Cao had to refute the authenticity of the tomb, the final consensus: Anyang, "Cao Cao's Tomb" in the discovery and excavation process, the existence of human planning, deliberate acts of fraud.

that car

Cao gaoling Hall in September Open: Ticket prices initially identified as 60 yuan

from Anyang, Henan Province Cao gaoling protection and utilization of leading group news, Cao Gao Ling Exhibition Hall opened in September, ticket prices initially identified as 60. Meanwhile, Cao Cao gaoling relics unearthed from the 250 to 400 pieces.

to meet the needs of local tourists gaoling temporary exhibition hall built in Cao Cao, after 3 months of intense construction, the exhibition hall and react building construction works coming to an end. According to Cao Gao Ling Anyang leading group for protection and utilization of the person in charge: "This Department Pavilion area of 787 square meters, completed, it will have the tour reception, show display and other functions." Gaoling visit react building planning and design full 291 meters, construction area is about 700 square meters. Now, Anyang City, Henan Province, and experts have compiled more than 20 million characters of text panels, more than 500 pieces of image data, is studying how to exhibit, will exhibit the work is expected to be completed in September, was formally opened by the end of September.

It is reported that Cao Cao gaoling archaeological work is almost complete. Tomb No. 1 and 2, Tomb of the clean-up work is expected to end before the end of September. The original heritage sector to the public, said the excavation found 250 artifacts. After repair, this figure increased to more than 400 pieces.

Zhexiang

23 experts reached a consensus after the discussion: Anyang, "Cao Cao's Tomb," the process of discovery and excavation, deposit acts of deliberate false

text of the doubt < / p>

stone tablet unearthed in a "modern text"

spokesman: Li Ping, an expert on stone, painting, Jiangsu Province Commission to identify

first need to say a few words, "Lu potential Epitaphs. " Lu potential, is a period after being Mishina Zhao official, and his epitaph in April 1998 excavation at Anyang. Lu Qian and Cao Cao was originally eight-pole Dabu Zhao, but because the epitaph that clearly detail the specific location of the tomb of Cao Cao, and thus verify the authenticity of the source of a link.

Li Lu Ping, said on "Epitaph of Lu Qian," the study found, "Epitaph of Lu Qian," there is a "year" and the words written, and it is now worded nearly the same, do not meet the official script writing rules. The "old" word to Lee Road, Ping felt suspicious, he said, in the Northern people to write "old" and the words should be written on half of the "stop" instead of "mountain." "Epitaph of Lu Qian" and "old" is precisely the upper part of the word "mountain", also do not meet the correct version.

and "Epitaph of Lu Qian," was also questioned that the same three pieces unearthed in the tomb of Cao Cao's "Heritage", "Wang Wei Wu often used?? Tiger Euphorbia", "Wang Wei Wu often used?? Tiger sword, "there was" often used by Wang Wei Wu Wei Xiang Shi. " The first two "heritage" of the "military" character and "Epitaph of Lu Qian," the second "force" written word as wrong to "stop" part was a "mountain." "Wang Wei Wu Wei Xiang Shi often used in" Totally in the "armed" and "Epitaph of Lu Qian," the first "armed" as the word "only" speak out too long under the cross, the wrong writing as "the" Department of difference more than 100 years, "Wu" wrote the wrong word, describe exactly the same craftsmen, the three "heritage" and "Epitaph of Lu Qian," the same person do the job.

"Also, from the" Epitaph of Lu Qian, "and the publication of Cao Cao Totally tomb rubbings of view, the above is no erosion of Carboniferous rocks in the ground to spend the millennium stone." Li Lu Ping said, "This clumsy forgery practices, the false time, longer than three years, short as long as three days. "

address the confusion

was not known as "Wei Wu Wang"

spokesman: Linkui Cheng, historians, Kaifeng, Henan Federation of Literary and Fine Art Commission Director

historians, Kaifeng, Henan Federation of Literary and Fine Art Commission Director Lin Kuicheng research the origin of the ancient name that the entire period of the Wei Dynasty (AD 220-265), the Cao Cao can not be called "Wei Wu Wang", with this Totally Appellation should not happen even in the tomb of Cao Cao.

Linkui Cheng said Cao Cao during his lifetime by the Chinese letters, first letters, "Wei Gong", following the closure, "The King." "Public" and "King" is Jazz number. But Cao Cao's death, "The King" is no longer Cao Cao, but Cao Pi, because Cao Cao Cao Pi's hereditary peerage. Cao Cao's death, posthumous title of "King Wu" can only be called his "King Wu" and will never be "Wei Wu Wang." The reason is simple, "The King" is alive Jazz number, is a remarkable name, "King Wu" is the posthumous name after his death, is the offerings were, the two mix, is against the system. Ancient Ceremonial demanding, Yang and Yin were certainly were not also used.

In addition, after the death of Cao Cao's Wei dynasty, called on Cao Cao's own, can only be three, that Taejo (Pi chasing after the posthumous title of the Temple name), Emperor Wu, Emperor Wu Taizu not may be known as "Wei Wu Wang." "And so anti-push, and now appears in the tomb of Cao Cao 'often used by Wang Wei Wu' series Pai, can only be false." Linkui Cheng says.

Stone disputes

Stone clearly saw file with the

spokesman: the Myth of China University of Political Science Department of Chinese, Ph.D., Wei Literature expert

been studying literature Professor Huang Zhenyun Wei, Cao Cao from Anyang tomb unearthed in terms of the Han Dynasty Stone Tomb of Cao Cao was the authenticity of research. Professor Huang Zhenyun said he would back in 2008, moving the car to see the tomb in Henan Anyang, Cao Cao made to an article entitled "Here is the tomb of Cao Cao," the ad, then Cao Cao's tomb can not be formally excavated tomb status not yet confirm how they will identify this tomb is the tomb of Cao Cao?

Professor Huang Zhenyun said that from some of Cao Cao's Tomb Stone published the picture shows, the picture is a replica of the Han Dynasty Stone Reliefs of Shandong Jiaxiang, the specific content with Shandong archaeologists did not find out what. The fake who found the best performance in battle scenes, images, and Cao Cao that this identity line. Just a joke busy.

Secondly, the style is from the Stone, Cao Cao tomb styles such as the Northern Wei Dynasty Stone carving a common line. Although the understanding of the Han Dynasty forge were carved stone relief law, but the low level of carved, modeled on the Northern line moment method, hat imitation Commission Han Guan.

"We can see from the picture, the entire image with a modern tool slot too deep, it means file with the saw, the border played too obvious oblique, or even stone prints, stone powder also cast in the above circumstances posing loess. "HUANG Zhen pointed projector picture said.

scale debate

I and how could the son of the tomb with the size

Speaker: Chang Kuo, Beijing Normal University, Dr. Wei Jinshi history, "subverting the Tomb of Cao Cao "On the

itself is Henan's Chang Kuo admitted that when first heard the tomb unearthed in Anyang of Cao Cao, the first reaction is Om gave the head, strange feeling, waking up the next day, laughed.

"because the 'Wei Wu Wang often used' square Pai is the most direct evidence is precisely the most compelling evidence against side. Putting aside the 'Wei Wu Wang' the title alone 'often used' these three words, no matter archeology or history are not the words, it does not set a precedent, it is quite 'Silver Buried Here' s too. "

Since then, Chang Kuo said he Transition from Graves, Cao Xiu late Eastern Han Dynasty tomb and the tomb has obviously similar, but the flat shape Anyang tomb of Cao Cao is with the Western Jin Dynasty tomb in Luoyang common pattern of the same two-bedroom, and a symbol of the tomb burial status within the main income level, Cao Cao and Cao Xiu actually are 7, I and the son of the tomb are actually the same size, status differences can not be displayed, so the West can not be the tomb of the high points of Cao Cao.

In addition, Chang Kuo-an said the historical record clearly Bian, Cao Chong Cao Cao have moved to and buried, but now can not prove the archaeological results. "No large-scale Peiling group, they did not find Bian's Queen's seal, and the bones of aged women are not in compliance, we going to overthrow the" Three Kingdoms, "many historical records you?"

sharp words:

"Liu Qing-chu, if not lie, I have a broken self"

Xi'an Municipal Party Hu, according to professor of history, historians, "Yi said the three countries" on

Anyang in Henan " Cao Cao's Tomb "in Crime in the role of Liu Qing-chu no one can match. Not only in their spare no effort, backed by even more because of its former director of the Chinese Institute of Archaeology, Acdemy honor, authoritative. However, think carefully about is not right, although the original Mr. Liu Fu school five cars, in the "Tomb of Cao Cao," but the identification of a lack of honesty.

proposed for Ni Mr. Fang Liu: "Cao Cao's Tomb" no epitaph is the largest Mishap. Liu Qing-chu proposed: (a), Cao Cao was not popular epitaph times; (b), first appeared in the Northern and Southern epitaph; (c), lay that amateur talk. Mr. Liu Qingzhu follow the idea, checked all relevant information, that it is not Mr. Liu said.

epitaph of a gradual process of formation followed the order: grave, grave + epitaphs, tombs + Epitaph + Ming Chung. Then later, an epitaph from the grave strip, complete a separate form. Eastern Han period, the nobles, the dead giants epitaph has been widespread. The epitaph is the epitaph of the complete form, however. Mr. Liu Qingzhu use small difference between the Epitaph and Epitaph, Epitaph of a hidden will, in the epitaph of a big issue there in time to occupy a war of words in an invincible position.

and Liu I would like to go with a polygraph test if I lied, people say that old and die for a thief, I self a break; if Liu Qing-chu lie, do not Mr. Liu had broken, please Lau Do not talk nonsense later, the tail clip up life!

have clear evidence of fraud tomb of Cao Cao

Ni side 6 grave robbers History of Chinese scholars, journalists, Nanjing University of Information Science Adjunct Professor School of Language and Culture, "the three great tomb" of

When a reporter's question, "one expert said that Hebei has to prove the hands of Cao Cao's Tomb in Anyang is clear evidence of fraud, why did not he come?"

Ni side 6 that the Expert Hebei Yan Pei is East, you can say for sure that his hands are clear evidence of false Anyang tomb of Cao Cao; he was (to Suzhou) Co., bought a train ticket, a refund may be temporary. He and the other is working closely with an agency, how to better expose the brewing (Anyang Cao Cao's tomb) of this scam.

, of course, he himself was also under great pressure, so this forum is not to reason in this regard. Although he did not come, but his paper is coming to. And his hands are indeed have the (false tomb that Cao Cao) evidence.