China Daily

newspaper Taiyuan July 4 (Xinhua Liu Xin Yan) Nowadays, around the entrance examination results are announced, candidates score once again thrown the spotlight, Shanxi Province, to continue this year, special provisions: In addition to candidates and I Admission schools, provincial Recruitment agencies not to any other departments and individuals to provide information about college entrance examination scores, cities, counties entrance examination administration nor to any other departments and individuals to provide online registration and examination results and other information.

the same time, Shanxi Province will no longer print the result slips, brochures and portfolio performance stickers, no statistics before the 20 branches and total score. This is the second consecutive year in Shanxi, "frozen" the top students, to avoid excessive "speculation."

2009 College Entrance Examination after the end of the Shanxi Provincial Department of Education on the introduction of specialized documents, said they did not publish the list and the identity of the top students, while non-local levels of government and administrative departments assigned to the general high school studies indicators; non-simple to college entrance examination ranking based on queuing or schools, principals and teachers, recognition reward and punishment.

relevant person in charge of Shanxi Province, a move aimed to help high school education, senses, return to law, to avoid emphasis on intellectual achievement test scores moral light and outlook on ideological bias.

He also said that no manipulation of the top students is to avoid the so-called "priority education", so that education for every student to achieve a balanced education.

supporters -

ranking alienation, no matter whether public

incompatible with the quality of education

Ordinarily, a ranking, a comparison a comparative, competitive, competition and development. However, the college entrance examination score rankings were alienated, as speculation of resources and the show's gimmick, the college entrance examination scores consecrated, and quality education intentions.

"Medium and Long Term Program for Educational Reform and Development (2010-2020)," stressed the overall quality of training, emphasis on people-centered thinking, human scientific development, which is "the only points of" the ranking is incompatible. To the majority of candidates, parents and the school's entrance examination pressure so the ranking does not matter whether row.

entrance is no longer ranked, not only do not do this thing is subjective, and more importantly, to further promote the reform of higher education institutions to recruit. Hope that with the deepening of reform, college entrance examination ranking proved unfounded.

- Party Propaganda Department of Tianjin University of Science and Technology Minister Zhengyun Wang

media should bear a great responsibility

Shanxi Province to take that step, should be affirmed. Scholars have been concerned about the complex is partly because the traditional concept, the scholar has always been the focal point of the community; the other hand, the media have a great responsibility, wanton speculation intensified this trend. Scholars of Hubei Province this year the list came out the next day the newspaper is a champion all the interviews and the like report, made me feel very uncomfortable.

this problem, the most fundamental is the "how to evaluate the community school" and "how schools evaluate students." Have to admit, that education today is still examination-oriented tendency is increased greatly, the community in order to evaluate the school enrollment rate is good or bad, the school to assess student performance advantages and disadvantages, 所有 revolve around Zhuo Zou scores and rankings. Thus pursuit champion, concerned about the ranking of the status quo can not be changed between a time.

course, the provincial government if they can make a determined effort to change this culture, the community should be affirmative. If you can make from the national level, a number of substantive appeals and long-term measures to enable the diversification of educational evaluation, the effect will be better.

- Dean of Education, Central China Normal University, China PhD supervisor, Professor Tu Yan

will influence the public to judge

I do not quite agree with the public champion of. If a school out of a champion, but the school itself is not very good, but the school propaganda, media propaganda, let us think that this school is the best.

Gongbu entrance champion, will affect students and parents teaching the whole school assessment of the situation they will use this single Jieguo to Hengliang the school, almost a point to face, forget to consider the school's overall teaching staff.

- Shanxi Taiyuan Foreign Languages School of Science candidate Jun Wang

not conducive to champion growth

not open fine. Because the results announced over the media publicity on the champion after the students grow, conservation area character may adversely affect the halo over his missing out feet on the ground may make modest natures.

but on the other hand, I was a teacher from the school perspective, the public is very beneficial. Fierce competition between schools, if you can develop a champion will be able to make this school stand out in the Area, the local competition made great advantage.

any case, the Champion should be the appropriate treatment of the principle of calmly top students.

- Hunan Hengyang year in high troupe Renchen Yi people

opponents -

more good than harm, not speculation like

champion should have halo

not publish scores of totally unnecessary. Similar to the Champion and Olympic champion, is in its own way to get this honor, they should have the halo.

our top students need not be taboo, the public are concerned about their psychological needs, we should adapt to the audience of this need. Other provinces open, but also not seen a big problem.

As to "promote the overall development of students", this is a good idea, but alone against the release of the top students, does not fundamentally solve the problem.

- Education and Research Institute of Xiamen University, Liu Haifeng

help talented people

as schools, announced the top students, to show the school's educational strengths and management level, to attract more high-quality source of students. Publish the list of students who champion the poor family can get more help.

, of course, the scholar, after all, only one, and the second, third gap is not, a very strong chance, only emphasized the neglect of champion two, three, students and teachers who are not students very unfair.

general, announced the selection position is conducive to talent, is an affirmation of educators, but should not be hyped.

- High School Nanyang City, Henan Xixia First Vice-President ZHAN cis

guide to strengthen the evaluation to be fair

child after so many years of hard study teachers use various methods tap the potential of students and ultimately have a good ranking, this is definitely the students and teachers. For students who do well, we share the joy of the children also have incentive effects.

see my children more light on the ranking, do not want the media frenzy.

for results and rankings, schools, parents, society should be guided to form a more objective and fair assessment.

- Hebei Province, the first liberal arts college entrance examination in 2010 Parents Zhi-Tao Liu

ranking is not published, affecting fill volunteer

If you do not publish scores and rankings will be Volunteers fill an impact on candidates.

because the candidates can refer to the position, determine their location, select a more appropriate school, if not announced candidates very easily become blind.

As against the release of the original purpose of college entrance examination ranking, is the all-round development, quality education, however, difficult to achieve the purpose of this instrument alone.

, if not published, competition between schools for admission requirements will still publish such information, many schools still use previous test how much a student, how many famous universities to attract students.

- Hengyang City, Hunan Province in the science of a candidate He Xinghui